Cyclopean masonryClassical antiquity
Dun Carloway
Also known asDoune Carloway · Dun Charlabhaigh · Dùn Chàrlabhaigh
Datedc. 1–100 CE
Photo Andrew Gray · CC BY-SA 4.0Source file on Wikimedia Commons
Overview
About this site
Overview
Dun Carloway (Scottish Gaelic: Dùn Chàrlabhaigh) is a broch in the district of Carloway on the west coast of the Isle of Lewis, Scotland, probably built in the 1st century AD. It is a scheduled monument and the best preserved broch in the Outer Hebrides.
On the east side parts of the old wall still reach 9 metres tall, and the wall rises on the south side to 9.2 metres. Only Mousa Broch and Dun Telve have walls that are higher.
Read on Wikipedia4 min readCC BY-SA 4.0
Where it sits in time
The site's dated range, placed against world reference points.
The scale is logarithmic: each step to the left is about ten times older than the last.
Article
Dun Carloway
Dun Carloway is built on a rock on a steep south slope at the height of 50 metres, overlooking Loch Carloway.
ConstructionSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Dun Carloway is built on a rock on a steep south slope at the height of 50 metres, overlooking Loch Carloway. The original height of the broch is unknown. The external diameter is 14.3 metres and the internal diameter of the inner courtyard is 7.4 metres. The walls vary in thickness from 2.9 to 3.8 metres from the south-east to the north.
The entrance is on the north-west side. It is 75 centimetres wide and 1 metre high, and the walls on this side do not much exceed the height of the entrance capstone. On the south side of the entrance passage is a so-called guard cell, a small side room whose opening is 61 centimetres square. In the interior there are three further openings. The opening on the eastern side, opposite the entrance, leads to the stairs between the walls, which run along one quarter of the circumference. The north-eastern opening gives access to an oval room, and the west opening gives access to a room under the staircase. In the south-eastern wall two large wall voids are visible, and on the north side of the interior the rock on which the broch was built protrudes.
It is likely that there was an upper wooden floor, as a scarcement (ledge) that could hold such a floor is visible 2 metres above ground level. Although the surviving wall is higher than nine metres, no trace of a higher scarcement has been found. This could mean that there was only one floor, or that a different method was used for higher floors.
FindsSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Limited archaeological excavation took place at the beginning of the 20th century and in the 1970s. Excavation in the north-eastern room found at least three peat ovens used in the period 400–700, together with a lot of pottery remains, a fragment of a quern-stone and a collection of snail shells. The fireplaces contained no animal bones, which makes domestic use for preparing meals seem unlikely, and an industrial use is also unlikely because of the absence of tools used in making ironwork. The room was probably used only for the manufacture of earthenware pots.
HistorySources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Dun Carloway remained in use until the floor level was too high because of the build-up of occupation layers. It was occasionally used in later times as a stronghold. The Morrisons of Ness put it into use in 1601. According to the story, they had stolen cattle from the MacAuleys of Uig, who found the Morrisons in the broch. Donald Cam MacAuley is said to have climbed the outer wall using two daggers and to have smoked out the inhabitants by throwing heather into the broch and setting fire to it. The MacAuleys then destroyed the broch.
By the middle of the 19th century a large portion of the top of the wall had disappeared, the stones being re-used in other buildings. The situation in 1861 is shown in a drawing published in 1890 by Captain Thomas.
NameSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
The name Dùn Chàrlabhaigh has as its first element dùn, meaning fort in Gaelic, commonly used in Scotland for prehistoric or early historic fortified sites, including brochs. The second element refers to the district of Carloway. Its exact meaning is uncertain, but most scholars connect it to Old Norse, reflecting the Norse settlement of the Hebrides between the 9th and 13th centuries. A widely accepted interpretation links it to the Old Norse personal name Karl with vágr, meaning bay or inlet, giving Karlavagr (Karl's bay).
ConservationSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
To prevent further decay, Dun Carloway was in 1882 made one of the first officially protected monuments in Scotland. Five years later, in 1887, the broch was placed under state management, and restoration has been carried out since then. It is now owned by Historic Scotland. The visitor centre is community owned and operated by the Carlaway Estate Trust (Urras Oighreachd Chàrlabhaigh).
ContextSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
A broch is an Iron Age hollow-walled drystone tower found in Scotland, which holds more than 500 of them. Brochs belong to the class that Scottish archaeologists call complex Atlantic roundhouses, and are concentrated in northern Scotland, with the densest groups in Caithness, Sutherland and the Northern Isles. The Atlas files them under cyclopean masonry because of the heavy drystone walls, but they are unrelated to the Mycenaean walls that give that term its name. Most brochs were built in the period from 100 BC to 100 AD.
Tradition and region
About this kind of monument
Scottish brochs
A broch is an Iron Age hollow-walled drystone tower found in Scotland, and Scotland holds more than 500 of them. Brochs belong to the class that Scottish archaeologists call "complex Atlantic roundhouses". There are approximately 571 candidate sites, concentrated in northern Scotland, with the densest groups in Caithness, Sutherland and the Northern Isles. The Atlas files them under "cyclopean masonry" because of the heavy drystone walls, but they are Scottish Iron Age buildings, unrelated to the Mycenaean walls that give that term its name.
The finest is the Broch of Mousa in Shetland, the tallest broch still standing and among the best-preserved prehistoric buildings in Europe; it is thought to have been built about 300 BCE. Midhowe Broch on Rousay in Orkney has an internal diameter of 9 metres within a wall 4.5 metres thick, which still stands more than 4 metres high. At the Broch of Gurness on Mainland Orkney, a village grew around a tower that probably once reached about 10 metres; settlement began between 500 and 200 BCE, and Robert Rendall found it in 1929.
Dating is not secure. Most brochs may have been built from about 300 BCE; a sheep bone at Old Scatness in Shetland dates to between 390 and 200 BCE. The old view that brochs were defensive refuges for people and their livestock has been challenged: it has been argued that they were the "stately homes" of their time, showing the status of important families, though there is no archaeological proof, and the purpose may have combined defensive, offensive and symbolic functions.
When visiting, look for the two skins of drystone wall with a stair or gallery between them, and for the settlement of smaller houses around the tower.
Paraphrased from Wikipedia: Broch, Wikipedia: Mousa Broch, Wikipedia: Dun Carloway, Wikipedia: Midhowe Broch, Wikipedia: Gurness Broch, Wikipedia: Cyclopean masonry · CC BY-SA 4.0
From the article
Dated moments in the story
- 100 BCE
Most brochs were built in the period from 100 BC to 100 AD.
Source - 700 CE
Excavation in the northeastern room found at least three peat-ovens used in the period 400–700. In this room were also a lot of pottery remains, as well as a fragment of a quern-stone and a collection of snail shells.
Source - 1601
The Morrisons of Ness put Dun Carloway into use in 1601. The story goes that they had stolen cattle from the MacAuleys of Uig.
Source - 1861
The situation in 1861 is shown in a drawing published in 1890 by Captain Thomas.
Source - 1882
To prevent further decay Dun Carloway was in 1882 made one of the first officially protected monuments in Scotland.
Source - 1887
Dun Carloway has been in state management since 1887 and is now owned by Historic Scotland.
Source
Photographs
8 photographs, each with its author and licence
More photographs
Lore
Evidence & Lore
What the sources actually support — and, kept apart, what has been claimed.
What the evidence supports
Dates
1–100 CEHow this date was established: Historical sourcesThe likely construction period is assigned to the 1st century AD within the broader 100 BC to 100 AD range used for most brochs.Source for this date
Measured facts
- Mainstream position
- Dun Carloway was probably built in the 1st century AD, remained in use until occupation deposits raised its floor level, and was occasionally reused later as a stronghold.Source: Mainstream position
- Site type
- Iron Age brochSource: Site type
- Location
- Carloway district, west coast of the Isle of Lewis, ScotlandSource: Location
- External diameter
- 14.3 metresSource: External diameter
- Internal courtyard diameter
- 7.4 metresSource: Internal courtyard diameter
- South wall height
- 9.2 metresSource: South wall height
- Official protection
- Made one of the first officially protected monuments in Scotland in 1882Source: Official protection
- Heritage designation
- scheduled monumentSource: Heritage designation
Alternative claims
Alternative claims about this site, kept in their own block and labelled with where they stand.
Donald Cam MacAuley climbed the outer wall with two daggers and smoked out the inhabitants by setting fire to heather, after which the MacAuleys destroyed the broch.
Where it stands
United Kingdom
The pin marks the monument itself — its exact point.
- Coordinates
- 58°16′11″ N, 6°47′38″ WFor a GPS or map app: 58.26961, -6.79397
Access is as our sources describe it; we have not visited the site to check.
Nearby
The closest sites in the Atlas, by straight line.
- Cyclopean masonryDun Stuigh,dun,Great Bernera390 BCE–200 CE
- Megalithic mound (tumulus with integral stones)Cnoc na Moine,burial cairn,Dalmore4000–800 BCE
- Megalithic mound (tumulus with integral stones)Cnoc Leathan,kerb cairn 230m S of,Upper Breasclete4000–800 BCE
- Chambered cairnCnoc a' Phrionnsa,chambered cairn4000–2500 BCE
- Megalithic mound (tumulus with integral stones)Beinn Bheag,standing stone,cairns and shielings 500m SSE of4000–800 BCE
- Cyclopean masonryDun Bharabhat, Great Bernera1800–100 BCE
Callanish VIII4000–2400 BCEPhoto: Original uploader was Tumulus at en.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0
- Chambered cairnCarnan Beag, chambered cairn 350m SSW of, Hacklete, Great Bernera4000–2500 BCE
Sources
Every record behind this page, with the link it came from.
2 sources behind this page
- 01Wikidata Q1265209wikidata.org
- 02Wikipedia (en)en.wikipedia.org
Image files
- Carloway - Dun Carloway - 20180411092751.jpgAndrew GrayCC BY-SA 4.0
- Dun Carloway.jpgPublic domain
- Doppelwand des Brochs Dun Carloway, Lewis.jpgGerritRCC BY-SA 4.0
- Dun Carloway 01.jpgPaulT (Gunther Tschuch)CC BY-SA 4.0
- Carloway Broch - geograph.org.uk - 1922419.jpgJohn FergusonCC BY-SA 2.0
- Dun Carloway Broch in the Snow.jpgMrdog10CC BY-SA 4.0
- Carloway Broch - geograph.org.uk - 2630291.jpgColin SmithCC BY-SA 2.0
- Carloway Broch - geograph.org.uk - 2025871.jpgCarol WalkerCC BY-SA 2.0
Report a correctionWrong date, name, photograph or source? Tell us and it will be put right.
Lore, kept apart
Legends and claims
These are stories and claims reported by the sources. They are not evidence, and they never stand in for the dating above.
- Tested: not supported
Donald Cam MacAuley climbed the outer wall with two daggers and smoked out the inhabitants by setting fire to heather, after which the MacAuleys destroyed the broch.
Source
Around this place
The ten nearest sites, by compass
- Dun Stuigh,dun,Great Bernera3.7 km W
- Cnoc na Moine,burial cairn,Dalmore5.3 km NE
- Cnoc Leathan,kerb cairn 230m S of,Upper Breasclete5.9 km SE
- Cnoc a' Phrionnsa,chambered cairn6.0 km SE
- Beinn Bheag,standing stone,cairns and shielings 500m SSE of6.4 km SE
- Dun Bharabhat, Great Bernera6.6 km SW
- Callanish VIII7.4 km S
- Carnan Beag, chambered cairn 350m SSW of, Hacklete, Great Bernera8.1 km SW
- Callanish8.4 km S
- Calanais Standing Stones8.5 km S
Credit
Text, licence and sources
Adapted from the Wikipedia article "Dun Carloway" (English), licensed CC BY-SA 4.0; authors are listed in the page history. Reused under CC BY-SA 4.0. Read on Wikipedia · Edit history and authors
- Wikipedia (English): Dun CarlowayCC BY-SA 4.0
- Wikidata Q1265209CC0