MegalithFringe site
Bimini Road
DatedEst. 1000 BCE–900 CE
Photo Original picture by NASA · Public domainSource file on Wikimedia Commons
Overview
About this site
Overview
The Bimini Road, sometimes called the Bimini Wall, is an underwater rock formation near the island of North Bimini in the Bimini chain of islands, The Bahamas. It consists of a 0.8 km (0.50 mi)-long northeast-southwest linear feature composed of roughly rectangular limestone blocks.
Various claims have been made for the feature being a wall, road, pier, breakwater or other man-made structure, but credible evidence or arguments for such an origin are lacking. The consensus among geologists and archaeologists is that it is a natural feature composed of beachrock.
Read on Wikipedia4 min readCC BY-SA 4.0
Where it sits in time
The site's dated range, placed against world reference points.
The scale is logarithmic: each step to the left is about ten times older than the last.
Article
Bimini Road
Descriptions in various books and articles are said to exaggerate the regularity and rectangularity of the blocks.
DescriptionSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
The Bimini Road is the largest of three linear features. It trends northeast/southwest and has a pronounced hook at its southwest end. It consists of flat-lying, tabular, roughly rectangular, polygonal and irregular stone blocks measuring as much as 3–4 metres (10–13 ft) in horizontal dimensions, with the average size being 2–3 metres (7–10 ft). The larger blocks show complementary edges, which are lacking in the smaller blocks. Two similar, narrower and shorter linear features, approximately 50 and 60 m (160 and 200 ft) long, lie parallel to and shoreward of the Road; they consist of smaller blocks only 1–2 m (3–7 ft) in maximum horizontal breadth. Descriptions in various books and articles are said to exaggerate the regularity and rectangularity of the blocks.
The blocks have rounded corners and resemble giant loaves of bread. They consist of limestone composed of carbonate-cemented shell hash called beachrock, which is native to the Bahamas. The highly rounded form of the blocks indicates that a significant thickness of their original surface has been removed by biological, physical and chemical processes, so that tool marks or inscriptions would be unlikely to have survived.
Research historySources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
On September 2, 1968, while diving in 5.5 meters (18 feet) of water off the northwest coast of North Bimini, Joseph Manson Valentine, Jacques Mayol and Robert Angove encountered what they called a pavement of rounded stones of varying size and thickness.
After a detailed examination, Gifford and Ball reported that the three features are unconnected at the southwest end, that no evidence exists of two courses of blocks or of a single block set squarely atop another, that bedrock closely underlies the whole area, and that the blocks of the inner and middle features have always rested on a layer of loose sand. They saw no regular or repeated patterns of grooves that might be interpreted as tool marks. These observations are disputed by other investigators, who claim that a second course of blocks can be seen where sand has washed away; detailed evidence for a continuous second layer has not been published in a reputable scientific venue.
DatingSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
In 1979, Calvert and others reported radiocarbon dates from a core collected from the Bimini Road by E. A. Shinn in 1977. Whole-rock samples gave 2780±70 14C yr BP (UM-1359), 3500±80 14C yr BP (UM-1360) and 3350±90 14C yr BP (UM-1361); shells extracted from the beachrock core gave 3510±70 14C yr BP (UM-1362); and the carbonate cement gave 2770±80 14C yr BP (UM-1364) and 2840±70 14C yr BP (UM-1365). The shells are therefore older than the cement that holds them together as beachrock. The dates are interpreted as showing that the beachrock formed about 2,800 radiocarbon years ago by the cementation of sediments that had accumulated about 1,300 years earlier. Davaud and Strasser concluded that the beachrock layer formed beneath the surface of the island and was exposed by coastal erosion only about 1,900 to 2,000 years ago.
Proponents of a man-made origin argue that the radiocarbon dates are invalid because of contamination by younger carbon. A uranium-thorium date of 14,992±258 BP (7132-19/2) from the marine limestone underlying the beachrock, published by Gifford and Ball, is often cited in support of an artificial origin. It is regarded as invalid because the sample was partially recrystallised and because sea level about 15,000 calendar years ago stood between 95 and 100 metres (312 and 328 feet) below its present level. The underlying marine limestone is dated to the Sangamonian Stage, the last interglacial.
InterpretationSources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
Sources for this section
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
Eugene Shinn, Marshall McKusick, W. Harrison, Mahlon M. Ball, J. A. Gifford, Eric Davaud and A. Strasser all concluded after inspecting or studying the Bimini Road that it consists of naturally jointed beachrock. According to Davaud and Strasser, a beach sequence built the shoreline of North Bimini seaward, freshwater cementation created a band of semilithified sediment beneath the island's surface, and later shoreline erosion exposed this band in the intertidal zone, where it became beachrock. As the sediments beneath were eroded down to Pleistocene limestone, the beachrock broke into the flat-lying blocks observed today.
Tradition and region
About this kind of monument
Other prehistoric stone monuments
The Atlas uses the heading "other" for stone monuments that fit none of its other types, and the same article serves for underground chambers that have no regional article. The records are varied. Many are ziggurats, Egyptian temples and pyramids, and Maya and Andean sites, which are treated in their own articles. What remains is a scatter of single sites in many countries whose descriptions do not allow a closer classification.
Several of these are underground. A hypogeum is literally an "underground" temple or tomb, often with niches for cremated remains or loculi for buried remains. An early example is found at the Minoan Bronze Age site of Knossos on Crete, a beehive-shaped vault cut into soft rock. The Hypogeum of Ħal Saflieni in Paola, Malta, is the oldest example of a prehistoric hypogeum, with its earliest phase dated to 3600 to 3300 BCE. It is a complex of underground chambers, halls and passages covering about 500 square metres on three levels, partly carved to imitate temple architecture and containing extensive prehistoric art.
A rock-cut tomb is cut into an existing rock formation, usually a cliff or sloping rock face, and was a common burial form for the wealthy in several parts of the world. Famous clusters are in Egypt, Iran, Lycia in Turkey, Petra in Jordan and Sicily. Phrygian rock-cut tombs such as the Midas monument date to about 700 BCE, and Etruscan ones to about 500 BCE.
The general rule for these records is that the type tells you how a monument was made, not who made it or when. Dating is taken from the source for each site where a source gives one, and otherwise left as a broad range.
When visiting, read the site's own description first, since the Atlas can offer only a general frame.
Paraphrased from Wikipedia: Megalith, Wikipedia: Hypogeum, Wikipedia: Rock-cut tomb, Wikipedia: Stele · CC BY-SA 4.0
From the article
Dated moments in the story
- 1421
In his debunked pseudohistorical book 1421: The Year China Discovered America, amateur historian Gavin Menzies falsely claimed that when Chinese admiral Zheng He's fleet was circumnavigating the globe from 1421 to 1423, it stopped at Bimini.
Source - 1968
On September 2, 1968, while diving in 5.5 meters (18 feet) of water off the northwest coast of North Bimini, Joseph Manson Valentine, Jacques Mayol and Robert Angove encountered what they called a "pavement" of what later was found to be noticeably rounded stones of varying size and thickness.
Source - 1971
In a 1971 Argosy article, Marx reported that Carl H.
Source - 1977
Shinn in 1977 from the Bimini Road.
Source - 1978
In 1978, the radiocarbon laboratory operated by the Department of Geology at the University of Miami dated samples from a core collected by E.
Source - 1979
In 1979, Calvert and others reported dates of 2780±70 14C yr BP (UM-1359), 3500±80 14C yr BP (UM-1360), and 3350±90 14C yr BP (UM-1361) from whole-rock samples; a date of 3510±70 14C yr BP (UM-1362), from shells extracted from the beachrock core; and dates of 2770±80 14C yr BP (UM-1364) and 2840±70 14C yr BP...
Source
Photographs
2 photographs, each with its author and licence
More photographs
Lore
Evidence & Lore
What the sources actually support — and, kept apart, what has been claimed.
What the evidence supports
Dates
Est. 1000 BCE–900 CEHow this date was established: Type comparisonTypological estimate, not a date for this site: a other in the Caribbean is normally dated between 1000 BCE and 900 CE (Atlas typological table).Source for this date
Measured facts
- Mainstream position
- The formation is generally considered a natural geological feature, and no evidence supports the claim that Zheng He's fleet constructed it.Source: Mainstream position
- Location
- near North Bimini in the BahamasSource: Location
- Length
- 0.8 km (0.50 mi)Source: Length
- Orientation
- northeast-southwestSource: Orientation
- Composition
- roughly rectangular limestone blocksSource: Composition
- Accepted origin
- naturally occurring geological featureSource: Accepted origin
Alternative claims
Alternative claims about this site, kept in their own block and labelled with where they stand.
The Bimini Road is an artificial structure, possibly an ancient road, wall, pier, or breakwater.
Zheng He's fleet built the formation from beach rock and ballast as a slipway after a hurricane near Bimini.
Tested: not supportedSource for this claim: Zheng He's fleet built the formation from beach rock and ballast as a slipway after a hurricane near Bimini.
Where it stands
The Bahamas
The pin marks the monument itself — its exact point.
- Coordinates
- 25°45′54″ N, 79°16′48″ WFor a GPS or map app: 25.76500, -79.28000
Access is as our sources describe it; we have not visited the site to check.
Nearby
The closest sites in the Atlas, by straight line.
Sources
Every record behind this page, with the link it came from.
2 sources behind this page
- 01Wikidata Q2734050wikidata.org
- 02Fringe claim sourceen.wikipedia.org
Image files
- Bimini island.jpgOriginal picture by NASAPublic domain
- Bimini Islands from 30,000 feet - panoramio.jpgJesseGCC BY-SA 3.0
Report a correctionWrong date, name, photograph or source? Tell us and it will be put right.
Lore, kept apart
Legends and claims
These are stories and claims reported by the sources. They are not evidence, and they never stand in for the dating above.
Around this place
The ten nearest sites, by compass
Credit
Text, licence and sources
Adapted from the Wikipedia article "Bimini Road" (English), licensed CC BY-SA 4.0; authors are listed in the page history. Reused under CC BY-SA 4.0. Read on Wikipedia · Edit history and authors
- Wikipedia (English): Bimini RoadCC BY-SA 4.0
- Wikidata Q2734050CC0